Best Crabgrass Killer that Won’t Kill Grass [Top 8 + Reviews]

Crabgrass is a grassy weed that’s tough to kill with most combination herbicides. In fact, some post-emergent herbicides can damage your lawn while acting on crabgrass. So, what’s the best crabgrass killer for lawns that probably won’t kill grass?

The best crabgrass killer for lawns is Tenacity Turf Herbicide. It is a safe selective systemic herbicide that won’t kill lawn grasses such as KBG, perennial ryegrass, tall fescues, and centipede grass. Tenacity can be applied at seeding or on established lawns. Do not apply it on paspalum, kikuyu grass, and bermudagrass.

Below is a review of the best crabgrass killers (post-emergent herbicides) for lawns with different turfgrasses to help you find a great grassy weed killer that won’t harm your lawn.

8 Best Crabgrass Killers

While there are many herbicides on the market that can kill crabgrass, it is important to consider your grass type, country restrictions, whether it is safe for lawns, and if it has any other benefits (e.g. weed and feed formulas). You can also choose between granular and liquid crabgrass killers, but this is generally a personal preference.

From my practice, I look at the active ingredient and its mode of action to determine the best crabgrass killer for any lawn.

Here are the best crabgrass killers with my review information:  

1. Tenacity Turf Herbicide

Best crabgrass killer - Tenacity Turf Herbicide

Tenacity Turf Herbicide is the best crabgrass killer that won’t kill grass in your lawn because its active ingredient is a a selective herbicide. It will target crabgrass by inhibiting photosynthesis, forcing the grassy weeds to die.

The great thing about Syngenta’s Tenacity Turf Herbicide is that it is a 2-in-1 formulation that acts as both a pre-emergent and a post-emergent weed killer. It destroys weeds to the root, making it highly effective at controlling grassy weeds in lawns.

  • Active ingredient: Mesotrione
  • Mode of action: selective herbicide

List of weeds Tenacity kills

Crabgrass, goosegrass, barnyardgrass, and yellow foxtail, Dandelion, Nutsedge, creeping bentgrass, nimblewill. Mesotrione will also control some broadleaf weeds in lawns such as clover, purslane, wild carrot, dandelion, henbit, chickweed, and thistle.

Indications and Safety for Lawn Use

Tenacity turf herbicide is safe for use in Kentucky Bluegrass, St. Augustine grass, tall fescue, fine fescue, and centipedegrass.

Caution: Do not spray tenacity turf herbicide on lawns with Bermuda grass, paspalum, zoysia, kikuyu grass, bentgrass, or poa annua. This herbicide is indicated as dangerous and can cause injury to these turfgrasses. If you want to use it in lawns established with these turfgrasses, ensure you only spot-treat the weeds to kill them.

See tenacity product label here.

The only other chemical crabgrass herbicide that won’t kill grass is Scotts® Spot Weed Control – For Lawns, which is formulated to target selected weeds and kill them to the root without harming lawns.

2. Drive XLR8 Herbicide Crabgrass Killer

Best crabgrass killer that won't kill grass
  • Fastest crabgrass killer with results in 2 days.
  • Provides residual control (30-45 days).
  • Rainproof within 1 hour.
  • Controls more than just crabgrass.

My review: With a single application, the crabgrass in my lawn started to die on the third day.

Drive XLR8 is a water-based crabgrass formulation that I’ve found to be the most effective at controlling crabgrass and a couple of other stubborn weeds in lawns.

Being a water-based concentrate, it is quickly absorbed by the target weeds, killing them systemically within a day or two.

Here’s more information from my review:

Active ingredientQuinclorac (18.92%)
List of weeds killedCrabgrass, dandelion, dollarweed, foxtail, signalgrass, clover, kikuyugrass, torpedograss, speedwell, and bindweed.
TypeSelective, post-emergent.
Safe forCommon bermudagrass, annual bluegrass, KBG, zoysia, ryegrass, buffalo grass.
Not safe forSt. Augustine grass, bahiagrass, bentgrass, carpetgrass.

The active ingredient in Drive XLR8 is quinclorac, which is known to kill crabgrass with great success. It is also safe for some turfgrasses, so it won’t kill grass in your lawn if you apply as per the label.

The herbicide is absorbed through roots and foliage and then translocated throughout the plant. Within a few days of applying Drive XLR8 on crabgrass, I noticed signs of destruction such as stunted growth, chlorosis, and gradual death of crabgrass and other grassy weeds in my lawn.

On the downside, I noticed that even in tolerant species of grass, Drive XLR8 can cause a little discoloration when applied on the turf. This is a disadvantage that you can overcome by adding a little chelated iron to the spray mix. Alternatively, use a liquid spray of nitrogen fertilizer.

After testing extensively, I noticed that some types of crabgrass, especially smooth crabgrass did not respond to the application of this post-emergent herbicide.

See the Drive XLR8 Crabgrass Killer product label.

3. AgraLawn Organic Crabgrass Killer

Agralawn Natural Crabgrass Killer that Won't Kill Grass
  • The best organic crabgrass killer.
  • Kills crabgrass but not grass in your lawn.
  • Safe for pets and humans.
  • Kills crabgrass to the root.
  • Acts fast – killing crabgrass within 5 days.

There aren’t plenty of natural crabgrass killers out there, but AgraLawn Organic Crabgrass Killer is one of the best for getting rid of crabgrass in lawns.

The active ingredient, cinnamon bark, is indicated for controlling both smooth and hairy types of crabgrass without harming lawns.

AgraLawn Organic Crabgrass killer is indicated as best used in lawns with St. Augustine grass, Bermuda grass, bahia grass and centipede grass.

If you’re using it on other turfgrasses that aren’t indicated as tolerant, you might want to use spot treatment to get rid of the grassy weeds in your lawn.

On the test patches I used AgraLawn natural crabgrass killer, I was able to get rid of the weed within 5 days. Wilting and discoloration started to occur at 3 days, and by the 5th day, the crabgrass was dead.

See the AgraLawn product label.

4. Quali-Pro Select Source Quinclorac 75 DF Herbicide

Quali-Pro Select Source Quinclorac 75 DF Herbicide for crabgrass
  • Highly effective selective crabgrass post-emergent.
  • Kills other grassy and broadleaf weeds as well.
  • Acts as a crabgrass pre-emergent in bermudagrass lawns.
  • Kills crabgrass and won’t kill grass.
  • Safe to apply before and after seeding in most turfgrasses.

The Select Source Quinclorac 75DF is a dry formula with 75% quinclorac as the active ingredient. From my tests, it is effective at controlling crabgrass and a number of other broadleaf weeds without killing turfgrass.

Being a selective herbicide, it is safe for use in Bermuda grass as a pre-emergent herbicide, which is great since I did not have to buy a crabgrass preemergent for my lawn.

Here’s information I think is important from my review:

Active ingredientQuinclorac (75%)
List of weeds killedCrabgrass, Torpedograss, Barnyardgrass, Foxtail, Kikuyugrass, Signalgrass, Clover, Daisy, Dandelion, Dollarweed, Geranium, Bindweed, Medic, Morningglory spp., Speedwell,and Violet.
TypeSelective, post-emergent and pre-emergent in Bermuda grass lawns.
Safe forBermudagrass, bluegrass, annual bluegrass, kentucky, buffalograss, tall fescue, ryegrass, zoysiagrass
Not safe forSt. Augustine grass, Bahiagrass, Colonial Bentgrass, Seaside Bentgrass, Centipedegrass, and Dichondra.

See Select Source Quinclorac 75 DF herbicide label here.

The major downside I saw when I tested Qunclorac on crabgrass is that it does not get rid of crabgrass with one application. I had to apply the herbicide twice to see success – which I did.

5. Image Crabgrass Killer

IMAGE lawn weed and crabgrass killer - best crabgrass killer that won't kill grass
  • Image kills crabgrass but not grass.
  • Controls over 200 weeds in lawns.
  • Can be applied on both cool-season and warm-season grass.
  • Systemic – kills crabgrass to the root.

The active ingredients that make it so potent at killing crabgrass include MCPA, dimethylamine salt, quinclorac, and Dicamba. These ingredients are indicated for killing over 200 different types of weeds in lawns and yards.

Image is one of the best crabgrass killers you can use to get rid of grown grassy weeds in your lawn. What I like most about this herbicide is that it won’t harm your lawn. Instead, it selectively controls crabgrass and a few other stubborn grassy weeds.

 Here’s more information from my review of Image crabgrass killer.

Active ingredientMCPA, dimethylamine salt, quinclorac, and Dicamba
List of weeds killedKills major broadleaf and stubborn grass weeds including dandelion, chickweed and clover as well as crabgrass and foxtail.
TypeSelective, post-emergent
Safe forKentucky bluegrass, Ryegrass, perennial and annual,Tall fescue, Bentgrass, fine Fescues, Bermudagrass, Zoysiagrass, Buffalograss.
Not safe forSt. Augustinegrass, Bahiagrass, Centipedegrass, Carpetgrass, Seashore paspalum.

See Image Weed Killer for Lawns and Crabgrass label.

6. Spectracide Weed Stop For Lawns Plus Crabgrass Killer

Spectracide weed stop for lawns plus crabgrass killer
  • Acts fast – results in 5 hours.
  • Does not harm the good grass.
  • Kills nutsedge and 470 other lawn weeds.
  • Rainproof within 3 hours.
  • Destroys crabgrass to the root.

The mix of active ingredients in Spectracide Weed Stop for Lawns Plus Crabgrass Killer make it so potent that it destroys a huge list of weeds. Being a selective herbicide, I used it to kill weeds in a large area in my lawn, and it worked.

Crabgrass started to die within a few hours – showing signs of wilting and chlorosis, meaning the herbicide worked.

Active ingredient2,4-D, dimethylamine salt (3.74%), Quinclorac (1.79%), Dicamba dimethylamine salt (0.43%), and Sulfentrazone (0.22%).
List of weeds killedCrabgrass, dandelion, Chickweed, purslane, foxtail, yellow nutsedge. The label indicates it kills over 400 other weeds.
TypeSelective, post-emergent
Safe forKentucky bluegrass, fescue, perennial ryegrass, Bermudagrass, zoysia, buffallo grass.
Not safe forSt. Augustine grass, bentgrass, bahiagrass, centipedegrass, carpetgrass.

I tested this herbicide on crabgrass in a Bermuda grass lawn. I was worried since the grass started to turn yellow after a day. Later, the crabgrass died and the Bermuda lawn recovered.

My bad…I must’ve missed that part of the label because it is clearly indicated on there, so be sure to read it carefully before applying it on your lawn.

Download the Spectracide Weed Killer product label here.

7. Ortho Weed B Gon Plus Crabgrass Control

best crabgrass herbicide for lawns - Ortho Weed B Gon
  • Kills crabgrass but won’t harm lawn grass.
  • Destroys 250 other weeds.
  • Systemic herbicide and will kill weeds to the root.
  • Best fast acting crabgrass killer – results in hours.

Being a highly-rated postemergent herbicide for killing crabgrass, I went ahead and tested it on a St. Augustine grass lawn. Sure, it is sold in a ready-to spray bottle, making it easy to spot-treat areas with extensive weeds.

It worked great as a selective weed killer because it did not kill my turfgrass. Dandelions and clovers died within a few hours. I started seeing crabgrass yellowing and drooping the following day, and it seems it worked just fine.

The one issue I have with Ortho Weed B Gon as a top crabgrass killer product is that it is too expensive and may not be suitable for extensive weed infestations.

Also, it caused discoloration on Bermuda grass lawns, but the grass recovered within a few days and grew greener and thicker.

8. BioAdvanced All in One Lawn Weed and Crabgrass Killer

BioAdvanced All in One Lawn Weed and Crabgrass Killer herbicide
  • Kills crabgrass but won’t kill grass.
  • Rainproof within 1 hour of application.
  • Kills weeds to the root, providing effective control.
  • Kills grassy + boadleaf lawn weeds.

This product used to be the Bayer Advanced All in One Weed and Crabgrass killer for lawns. The name change did not change the quality.

It is a potent formulation that selectively kills crabgrass and many other grassy and broadleaf weeds in lawns without harming grass.

Being one of the best crabgrass killers, it works as a systemic herbicide, killing crabgrass to the root. It will also act on other turfgrass weeds such as foxtail, barnyard grass and many other listed weeds.

Active ingredient2,4-D, dimethylamine salt (4.85%), Quinclorac (1.61%), Dicamba, dimethylamine salt (0.45%)
List of weeds killedCrabgrass, barnyardgrass, dandelion, black medic, foxtails, bull thistle, , chickweed, wild garlic, clovers, wild onion
TypeSelective, post-emergent
Safe forZoysia, Bermudagrass, Kentucky Bluegrass, Bentgrass Ryegrass, Buffalograss, Fescue.
Not safe forSt. Augustine grass – Floratam included, Bahiagrass, Centipedegrass, Carpetgrass.

Like quite a few other top rated crabgrass weed killers on this list, BioAdvanced All in One herbicide caused yellowing on my bermuda grass lawn. However, the lawn recovered quite easily and restored its color.

Other great crabgrass killers for lawns include MSMA herbicide and Greenlight Wipe-Out Crabgrass Killer.

When spring comes, lawn care and maintenance work begins. To get a great-looking lawn throughout the season, you must prevent and kill weeds early enough.

The herbicides I’ve reviewed here are post-emergent applications. You can only use them to kill and control crabgrass weeds already established in your lawn. If you want to get rid of crabgrass before it germinates, you might want to consider applying a crabgrass preventer early in spring.

3 thoughts on “Best Crabgrass Killer that Won’t Kill Grass [Top 8 + Reviews]”

  1. Get a broad leaf weed killer that’s safe for lawns from home depot and use that. Don’t waste your money on pylex and tenacity to kill broadleaf weeds. For crabgrass you want something that has quinclorac in it. Look for something like a orthoweed begone/ crabgrass killer. Or roundup for lawns.

  2. I add tenacity as a kicker to all my herbicide applications and use a NIS. the tenacity adds a different mode of action and broadens the kill. I even add it to my sledgehammer when targeting nutsedge. I never consider using it alone unless I am targeting bentgrass or nimblewill. I have used it when seeding but prefer sidiron as pre-emergent when seeding

  3. Hello, My lawn is full of crabgrass and poa! I am planning on reseeding in September with cool-season grass seeds. I’ve just applied tenacity as post emergent (blanket) and was planning to do a spot treatment in two weeks time and then maybe do lawn renovation a week after so in summery my plan was to reseed/ autumn renovation three weeks after blanket application of tenacity. My rationale was to try and kill weed before reseeding to give new seed/grass better chance to grow.

    However, I’ve read somewhere that if I don’t reseed within a week of tenacity application, I have to wait 6-8weeks!! I’ve looked at tenacity bottle and nothing mentioned about that!

    Your help will be really appreciated as waiting 6-8 weeks isn’t an option. Thanks a lot.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top